Aamir Khan's 'Sitaare Zameen Par' Aims for the Heart and Scores
Aamir Khan’s much-anticipated return to the big screen, Sitaare Zameen Par, arrives as a spiritual successor to his beloved 2007 classic, Taare Zameen Par. The film, an official adaptation of the 2018 Spanish comedy-drama Campeones, tells a heartwarming story of redemption, connection, and the power of seeing beyond labels. While early reviews suggest the film takes its time to find its rhythm, it ultimately delivers a powerful emotional and comedic punch, particularly in its second half.
A Story of Unlikely Redemption
The film centers on Gulshan Arora (Aamir Khan), an egotistical and hot-tempered assistant basketball coach. After a public outburst gets him suspended and a drunk driving incident lands him in legal trouble, he is sentenced to community service: coaching a basketball team of specially-abled adults for three months. Initially reluctant and resentful, Gulshan embarks on a journey where he, the coach, ends up being the one who learns the most profound lessons about life, patience, and humanity.
A Narrative Without Villains
A key strength highlighted in reviews is the film's sensitive and dignified portrayal of its specially-abled characters. The narrative skillfully avoids the trap of seeking sympathy. Instead, it presents the team members as fully-realized adults with their own distinct personalities, desires, and flaws. They are not defined by their conditions but by their humanity. This approach allows the film to generate genuine humor and connection, celebrating their unique perspectives on what it means to be "normal" without resorting to pity.
A Game of Two Halves
Critics have noted that the film is a tale of two distinct halves. The first act is described as slow-paced, testing the audience's patience as it establishes Gulshan's initial struggles with his new role and his strained marriage to Sunita (Genelia D'Souza). However, the narrative reportedly finds its footing miraculously after the intermission. The second half is praised for its sharp humor, emotional depth, and rousing sequences that build to a rewarding climax. Aamir Khan's performance is cited as a consistent strength, carrying the film through its slower moments and shining in the comedic and emotional scenes. The ensemble cast playing the basketball team has also been lauded for their authentic and heartwarming performances.
While the film may not capture the same lightning-in-a-bottle magic as its predecessor, Sitaare Zameen Par is being hailed as a heartfelt and sincere cinematic experience, one whose collective laughter and emotional resonance are best appreciated in a theatre.
